B-BBEE Scorecard Rating
Time to produce a BEE Scorecard
EconoServ helps companies become BEE compliant in the easiest and most effective manner. We have all-round solutions for your BEE compliance journey – Contacts us and we will find the best solution for your business.
With the gazetting of the B-BBEE Codes of Good Practice, some of your customers have started asking you about your BEE Status. As time goes on companies will need your BEE Scorecard more urgently and may start looking for alternative suppliers.
In a short period of time, any company that does business with any other company in South Africa or directly with government will need a BEE Scorecard for themselves and from all of their suppliers.
Every time your customer requests your BEE Scorecard you risk losing business by not responding. This gives your competition a very good opportunity of getting more business by giving your customer a better BEE Scorecard.
Give your customers a BEE Scorecard and stop running the risk of losing business.
How to respond?
What do you need to do?
Respond to all your customer’s requests: You should start off by saying to your customer that you intend becoming BEE compliant by following the seven elements of empowerment (Ownership, Management, Employment Equity, Skills Development, Preferential Procurement, Enterprise Development and Socio-economic Development). QSE’s (Qualifying Small Enterprise – companies with turnovers below R35 million) need to comply with any four but should still mention all seven. Small companies (below R5 million) are automatically compliant and should give their customers a statement describing in detail how and why they are compliant.
“Many companies requesting this information do not expect you to respond with good BEE scores as most recognize that this is a long term strategy and certainly not a project that can be achieved overnight.”
Once you have made contact with your customer you can now start working towards a BEE Scorecard and making your company BEE Compliant.
Working on your Scorecard
The best place to start is to read up on the BBBEE Codes, speak to experts and attend courses to get sufficient knowledge to start working on your BEE Scorecard. A well-presented introduction course should take no longer than half a day and should leave you with enough information about BEE to help you answer most questions.
After you have been through the BEE codes you should understand how the calculations work, the important definitions and a general overview of how each one of the seven elements of empowerment works. You should also start thinking about projects that your business currently runs or is considering.
|“Common projects are staff training, donations to charity, developing a colleague’s business and buying from good BEE contributors.”|
The BEE Scorecard
The next step is to look at the BEE Scorecard. This is the most valuable BEE document.
The BEE Scorecard gives your company targets to achieve and points to earn from participating in certain projects that contribute towards BEE. It allows your company to measure how compliant you are by taking into account various aspects of your business. This is why it is officially called the Broad-Based Black Economic Empowerment scorecard. A copy of the QSE and Generic scorecard is available in our downloads section (registration required).
You now need to start calculating how compliant your company is. We designed EconoBEE Scorecard (easy to use BEE Scorecard Rating software) for this exact purpose. Our software will explain everything that is relevant to you about the BEE Scorecard, help you collect and store documentation and help you provide proof. Ultimately EconoBEE Scorecard will print a summary scorecard (in certificate format) or a detailed profile giving details of all aspects of the BEE Scorecard, you will also sign it off as being accurate.
The 7 Elements
Look at each element
Who owns your company? Do you issue Economic Interest? Do the owners have full rights to the shares? Have the owners bought and paid for the shares? Are they paid for in full?
Who is the senior management in your company?
Do you have junior/middle and senior managers? What percentage of your employees are black? Do you employ black females at junior/middle or senior management?
Do you spend money on training your staff? Is it possible to spend additional money on training? Can you formalize in-house training? Is your training logged and calculated on an annual basis?
Are your supplier’s BEE compliant? Do you have a supplier assessment form? Have you asked your suppliers for their BEE Scorecards? Did your suppliers respond?
Do you invest in other black businesses? Did you make a profit last financial year? Can you spend additional money on investments with black businesses?
Do you donate to charities? Do you give charitable donations to needy black people? Can you spend more on charity?
After you have been through the elements on the BEE Scorecard you are almost complete. Make sure that you have claimed points in the correct elements. You need to check that each element has been calculated correctly. Collect proof for all aspects on the BEE Scorecard where you scored points. An important principle when producing a BEE scorecard is you must have proof relating to each element or else you can’t earn any points.
Write a brief report on your BEE Scorecard. This is a summary of all the elements on the BEE Scorecard where you scored points or where you believe you can potentially score points. You should describe how you achieved the points. This is a very useful document as this is what helps your customers interpret your BEE Scorecard. You must also include your goals and achievable targets so your customers see that you are intending on improving on your BEE Scorecard.
The Final Rating
The rating: You need to compile all of this information into an auditable format so that it can be checked and signed off with confidence. There is a very good chance that your accountant/auditor will help you with the authenticating of your BEE Rating.
The finalised BEE Scorecard can be rated by an accredited rating agency – not a single rating agency has been accredited and it is impossible to get an accredited rating until they are accredited.
If you have suitable proof for every element on your scorecard, then have a company fiduciary or auditor sign the scorecard. Note: if the scorecard is incorrect you will lose credibility with your customers.
The final Scorecard should be in the form of a certificate/summary scorecard which gives a customer your BEE contributor level and any other information that is important to them eg Ownership percentage.
The role of a rating agency Rating agencies are simply going to be used by companies to audit the pre-compiled BEE Scorecard. A rating agency is not allowed to consult with you to help you improve your scorecard – anyone who rates you is not allowed to consult and a consultant is not allowed to rate you.
A rating agency will check that the data given to them is accurate, they do not assist you with producing a scorecard. A consultant can produce a scorecard, help improve it, help collect data but not sign it as a final scorecard.